forwarded to the list from Jeff Nightbyrd
Michael Eisenstadt
michaele@ando.pair.com
Tue, 04 Dec 2001 07:29:30 -0600
Here a little item that I picked up from www.pravda.ru
that made me feel good:
Nightbyrd
APES COULD SPEAK, THOUGH THEY CANNOT
Three families of anthropoid apes possess an important
brain function connected with speech faculties. Earlier
it was supposed this function to be exceptionally a human
brain's prerogative. According to the BBC, investigators
in a Georgia university, carried out a resonance-
magnetic scanning of chimpanzee, baboon and gorilla
brains. Now the scientists are sure nobody has
investigated yet such an important structure of
anthropoid apes' brain. If their discovery is
corroborated, it will become one more important
contribution to the evolution theory: it will be clear
that early humans obtained the speech faculty before homo
sapiens and other big primates' ways dispersed forever.
In human brain there is the so-called Brock zone, one
of whose components is called the Broadmann-44 zone. Namely
this zone, situated mostly in the left cerebral hemisphere
and partly in the right one, is responsible for forming
speech. Claudio Cantalupo and William Hopkins from
Georgia State University were puzzled with the fact
that the apes also possessed this structure, though they
could not speak. It is not clear for what functions the
apes need this Brock zone, especially taking into account
that the primitive anthropoid apes' "language" is not
similar to complicated human speech. This could be
explained only with the role gesticulation played in
evolution of human speech. The anthropoid apes observed
by the investigators most often gesticulated with their
right hand, especially when they accompany their gestures
with a kind of voice signals. If the scientists' theory
is right, the left side of the zone-44 was gradually
enlarging, while both human predecessors and anthropoid
apes were learning to gesticulate and produce laryngeal
sounds. Though later, by unknown reasons, human gestures
and sounds grew into speech, while the apes' ones remained
the same gestures forever.